Top 20 Athletics & Sports from Indianapolis on Instagram Influencers by Follower Growth

Last updated: September 10, 2025

Total Athletics & Sports Influencers in Indianapolis, United States of America

243

Expected Reach

4.3M

Total Followers

15.5M

Avg Engagement

6.57%

Top 20 Creators

RankInfluencerLocationFollowersEngagementMonthly GrowthScore
1
Pat McAfee
@patmcafeeshow
LIVE M-Fri 12-3EST on ESPN & YouTube. Kicked off a SuperBowl. Undefeated at WrestleMania. #CollegeGameDay Saturday mornings. Let’s live.
Indianapolis, United States of America
2.9M
Followers
2.60%
Engagement
+1.9%(+53.3K)
5.2
2
Camryn Bynum
@cambeezy_24
In Jesus’ name I play | Indianapolis Colts DB | Berkeley GRADUATE | MambaMentality 🐍 | 🇵🇭 | MOVIEEE 🎬 | @bynumfaithfoundation @campbeezy_
Indianapolis, United States of America
237.0K
Followers
10.35%
Engagement
+6.7%(+14.9K)
9.0
3
TJ McConnell
@tjmcconnell
Wine Lover🍷 @offtheglasswines | @leedsunited 🔵⚪️🟡
Indianapolis, United States of America
194.6K
Followers
2.53%
Engagement
+5.2%(+9.6K)
5.5
4
Alex Palou Montalbo
@alexpalou
Driver for @chipganassiracing 2025 INDY 500 WINNER 🥛 2021, 2023, 2024 & 2025 INDYCAR CHAMPION 🏆🏆🏆🏆 Co-Owner @paloumotorsport #OneGoal
Indianapolis, United States of America
136.7K
Followers
7.82%
Engagement
+4.0%(+5.2K)
8.5
5
Nick, Whitney, Cash Rowley
@rowley.adventures
Adventure travel family, living out of a dream! + Experiences over things + Always active, always stoked + Do it scared + nick@rowleyadventures.com
Indianapolis, United States of America
400.7K
Followers
0.42%
Engagement
+0.7%(+2.9K)
6.8
6
Marcus Ericsson
@ericsson_marcus
Driver of the #28 @andrettiindy in @indycar 👊🏻 2022 INDY 500 Champion 🏆 Former @f1 driver 🏎
Indianapolis, United States of America
288.5K
Followers
0.82%
Engagement
+0.9%(+2.6K)
6.7
7
Joscelyn Roberson
@josc_roberson
TeamJosc@wmeagency.com 2024 Olympic Alternate UARK ‘28 World Champion WCC
Indianapolis, United States of America
157.4K
Followers
11.37%
Engagement
+1.7%(+2.6K)
8.2
8
Gary Shirley
@itsgarytime
Tender like chicken.
Indianapolis, United States of America
455.1K
Followers
6.08%
Engagement
+0.5%(+2.2K)
8.3
9
Neen 🦋
@danietraaa
Indianapolis, United States of America
152.4K
Followers
4.69%
Engagement
+1.3%(+1.9K)
8.5
10
Dario Franchitti
@dario_franchitti
Ellie’s husband, Dad to Sofia and Valentina. Used to drive in circles… sometimes fast sometimes not!!
Indianapolis, United States of America
99.1K
Followers
3.58%
Engagement
+1.7%(+1.6K)
8.5
11
Jamie Erdahl
@jamieerdahl
Host of the NFL Morning Show @GMFB & GMFB:OT March Madness @cbssports Sweatpants of the Day™️ Blind Listen, No Judgment 💿 🤍: 🧔🏻👧🏼🧒🏼👶🏼🐕‍🦺
Indianapolis, United States of America
115.6K
Followers
1.39%
Engagement
+1.4%(+1.6K)
6.5
12
Colton Herta
@coltonherta
Indycar Driver for @andrettiindy RMF
Indianapolis, United States of America
86.3K
Followers
1.43%
Engagement
+1.8%(+1.5K)
7.3
13
Scott Dixon
@scottdixon9
6 time INDYCAR CHAMPION | 2008 Indy 500 Winner PNC Honda #9
Indianapolis, United States of America
173.0K
Followers
7.91%
Engagement
+0.7%(+1.3K)
8.0
14
MacLaine Funsch
@maclaine_17
NFL Cheerleader • Penn State alum ♡︎ TikTok @maclaine_17 ♡︎ mental health advocate ♡︎ jersey girl ☘️🧿🌙📣🩰🪩🇮🇪🦖🪐📚🧶
Indianapolis, United States of America
29.5K
Followers
4.51%
Engagement
+3.8%(+1.1K)
8.1
15
khalil el gharbi
@khalilgharbi1920
Tunisia 🇹🇳/indy🇺🇸. Twitch partner I'm like 70% soccer and 30% everything else✨
Indianapolis, United States of America
79.0K
Followers
4.11%
Engagement
+1.3%(+1.0K)
7.8
16
Connor McCaffery
@connor_m30
Indianapolis📍Asst Coach @ Butler 🐶
Indianapolis, United States of America
94.3K
Followers
38.85%
Engagement
+1.0%(+942)
9.2
17
Dr. Ayngelia aka Star
@star_lift3r
Cat Mom 🐈‍⬛ My coach @paynterperiodization Owner @star.trainingsystems 💫 @uspc.pl Senior VP & Certified Coach Int'l Judge ⚪️🔴⚪️ 📣 Meet Director
Indianapolis, United States of America
19.3K
Followers
6.61%
Engagement
+4.4%(+819)
7.7
18
kaitlyn vincie
@kaitlyn_vincie
@nascaronfox reporter and host listen to @harvickhappypod Owner: @mountainmamacabin + @thecloud9cabin Enjoys a good joke and a strong whiskey
Indianapolis, United States of America
98.9K
Followers
4.81%
Engagement
+0.8%(+780)
8.1
19
EJ Speed
@district.5_
FORT WORTH, TX
Indianapolis, United States of America
31.3K
Followers
4.68%
Engagement
+2.5%(+776)
8.3
20
Juan Pablo Montoya
@jpmonty2
Racecar Driver
Indianapolis, United States of America
304.8K
Followers
0.00%
Engagement
+0.3%(+768)
7.0

About This Instagram Influencer Ranking

Discover the most influential creators in Indianapolis with our comprehensive ranking of the top 20 influencers on Instagram who post Athletics & Sports content. This data‑driven analysis identifies the content creators who are shaping conversations, driving trends, and commanding the highest engagement rates in 2025.

Key Insights & Metrics

  • Combined Reach: 4.3M potential impressions across all ranked influencers
  • Total Audience: 15.5M followers collectively following these creators
  • Average Engagement Rate: 6.57% - significantly above industry average
  • Market Coverage: 243 total influencers analyzed in this category

Audience Demographics & Reach

Audience analysis is currently unavailable.

  • Top Markets: no data
  • Gender Distribution: no data
  • Primary Age Group: no data
  • Languages: no data

Why This Ranking Matters

For brands and marketers, this ranking provides essential intelligence for:

  • Identifying high-performing influencers for partnership opportunities
  • Understanding audience demographics for targeted campaigns
  • Benchmarking engagement rates and growth metrics
  • Discovering emerging talent with strong growth trajectories
  • Analyzing competitive landscape in Athletics & Sports niche

For content creators, these insights help with:

  • Understanding industry benchmarks and performance standards
  • Identifying successful content strategies from top performers
  • Network building and collaboration opportunities
  • Setting realistic growth targets based on peer performance

Methodology & Data Freshness

Our rankings are generated using advanced algorithms that analyze multiple performance indicators:

  • Profile Score: Proprietary metric combining reach, engagement, and growth
  • Engagement Rate: Average interaction rate across recent content
  • Growth Velocity: Month-over-month follower growth and momentum
  • Content Consistency: Posting frequency and audience retention
  • Audience Quality: Authenticity scores and demographic relevance

Data is refreshed weekly to ensure you're always working with the most current information. Last update includes performance data through September 2025.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the fastest‑growing Athletics & Sports creator in Indianapolis on Instagram?

Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) is, as of September 2025, the fastest‑growing Athletics & Sports creator in Indianapolis on Instagram, with +1.9% monthly growth (+53.3K followers).

How many followers did Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) gain last month?

Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) gained about 53.3K followers last month (+1.9%).

Who grew more: Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) or Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24)?

Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) grew more than Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24) (53.3K vs 14.9K).

How is Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24) performing right now?

Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24) is growing at +6.7% (+14.9K) per month, with a Profile Score of 9.0 and average engagement of 10.35%.

How is TJ McConnell (@tjmcconnell) performing right now?

TJ McConnell (@tjmcconnell) is growing at +5.2% (+9.6K) per month, with a Profile Score of 5.5 and average engagement of 2.53%.

How is Alex Palou Montalbo (@alexpalou) performing right now?

Alex Palou Montalbo (@alexpalou) is growing at +4.0% (+5.2K) per month, with a Profile Score of 8.5 and average engagement of 7.82%.

How is Nick, Whitney, Cash Rowley (@rowley.adventures) performing right now?

Nick, Whitney, Cash Rowley (@rowley.adventures) is growing at +0.7% (+2.9K) per month, with a Profile Score of 6.8 and average engagement of 0.42%.

Who had the higher percentage growth: Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24) or TJ McConnell (@tjmcconnell)?

Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24) leads (6.7% vs TJ McConnell (@tjmcconnell) 5.2%).

What is the absolute follower gain of Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow)?

Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) gained about 53.3K followers last month (+1.9%).

What is the absolute follower gain of Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24)?

Camryn Bynum (@cambeezy_24) gained about 14.9K followers last month (+6.7%).

What is the absolute follower gain of TJ McConnell (@tjmcconnell)?

TJ McConnell (@tjmcconnell) gained about 9.6K followers last month (+5.2%).

What is the absolute follower gain of Alex Palou Montalbo (@alexpalou)?

Alex Palou Montalbo (@alexpalou) gained about 5.2K followers last month (+4.0%).

What is the absolute follower gain of Nick, Whitney, Cash Rowley (@rowley.adventures)?

Nick, Whitney, Cash Rowley (@rowley.adventures) gained about 2.9K followers last month (+0.7%).

Is Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) still a relevant creator?

Yes — Pat McAfee (@patmcafeeshow) has a Profile Score of 5.2, average engagement of 2.60%, and +1.9% (+53.3K) monthly follower growth, indicating high relevance.

What is a good engagement rate for Athletics & Sports in United States of America?

The average engagement rate for this category is 6.57%. Generally, rates above 7.9% are considered excellent, while rates above 5.3% are good. Engagement rates vary by platform, niche, and follower count - micro-influencers often have higher rates than mega-influencers.

How is the Profile Score calculated?

The Profile Score (0-10 scale) is a composite metric that weighs several factors: 40% engagement quality, 25% audience reach, 20% growth momentum, 10% content consistency, and 5% audience authenticity. A score above 7.0 indicates a high-performing influencer, while scores above 8.5 represent elite-tier creators.

Can I use this data for influencer marketing campaigns?

Yes! This ranking is designed to help brands, agencies, and marketers identify potential partnership opportunities. The data provides a starting point for campaign planning, competitor analysis, and market research. For detailed campaign analytics and contact information, consider upgrading to our professional tools.

What does monthly growth percentage mean?

Monthly growth shows the percentage change in followers over the past 30 days. Positive growth (green) indicates gaining followers, while negative growth (red) means losing followers. The number in parentheses shows the absolute follower change. High growth rates often indicate viral content or successful campaigns.

Why should I track influencers in Indianapolis?

Location-specific influencer tracking is crucial for targeted marketing campaigns. Local influencers often have higher engagement rates within their geographic area, understand cultural nuances, and can drive better ROI for region-specific products or services. They're particularly valuable for retail, hospitality, and location-based businesses.

How can I improve my ranking as an influencer?

Focus on these key areas: (1) Increase engagement by creating content that encourages comments and shares, (2) Post consistently to maintain audience interest, (3) Use relevant hashtags to expand reach, (4) Collaborate with other creators in your niche, (5) Respond to comments to build community, and (6) Analyze your best-performing content and create similar pieces.

Note: This ranking represents a snapshot of current instagram influence based on publicly available data. Rankings can fluctuate based on content performance, platform algorithm changes, and audience behavior. Use this data as one of several factors in your decision-making process.